In the week of October 19, Austin had one of its quietest luxury weeks of the fall. That week was split between the Formula 1 race at Circuit of the Americas and early voting. According to The Real Deal, only five publicly listed homes and condos in Austin and West Lake Hills priced at $2 million or more went under contract that week, about $15 million in total. That was half the previous week's volume.
One of the five was 2304 Indian Trail in Tarrytown. It is a 1947 bungalow that was taken down to the studs and rebuilt in 2012, with three bedrooms and about 3,000 square feet. It went under contract after six days on the market. The list price was $2.5 million, or $830 per square foot.
A buyer who has spent the year looking at Tarrytown on the portals has mostly seen numbers going down. Those numbers are accurate, but they measure something narrower than what one house is worth. In Tarrytown, the median and the average mostly track which houses happened to sell, how few there were, and how many luxury sales never reached the MLS. A buyer who prices a particular lot and the quality of the house on it will read this market more accurately than one who prices against the neighborhood's headline number.
An 11% drop, measured on whatever sold
The figure most people cite is from 2025. The Real Deal reported in February that the 252 Tarrytown homes sold during 2025 averaged $1.5 million. That was 11% below the $1.7 million average in 2024 and the steepest percentage decline of any Austin neighborhood. In the same year, the average in Westlake slipped about 1%, from $2.22 million to $2.19 million, and downtown's average held near $1 million.
Part of that decline is a real repricing. Greg Walling of Moreland Properties told The Real Deal that buyers from out of town who pushed prices up quickly during the pandemic have since "moved on or decided to go back home."
The rest comes from the mix of homes. An average across 252 sales combines original cottages from the 1940s and 1950s, rebuilt bungalows, new spec homes and lakefront estates, and those homes have little in common beyond the ZIP code. If fewer large new homes close in one year than the year before, the average falls even when no single house has lost value. Tarrytown has an unusually wide range of housing for a neighborhood its size, so its averages swing more than averages in a more uniform area.
Eighteen sales in July
The monthly figures show the same effect on a smaller scale. Unlock MLS's July 2026 ZIP Code Scorecard put the 78703 median at $1,075,000 for July 2026, down 27.3% from July 2025. It rated the ZIP "At-Risk."
That median rests on 18 sales for the whole ZIP, which covers more than Tarrytown alone. Ten of them were priced at $1 million or more, and those ten averaged 61 days on the market.
With only 18 closings, a few condos or original cottages closing in the same month can move the median by six figures. A 27% one-month drop in a market this small reflects the mix of that month's sales. For comparison, the Travis Central Appraisal District's 2026 release estimated that the average single-family market value across the county fell 1.8%. That is a much smaller decline, measured across far more homes.
The land held most of its gain
In Tarrytown, a large part of any price is the land, and land values here have behaved differently from house prices. In the same Real Deal report, citing the American Enterprise Institute's land price indicators, the price of an acre in 78703 rose by almost $1 million between 2021 and 2022. It had fallen back by about $100,000 by 2024.
So the land gave back about a tenth of the gain it made in a single year. Amy Deane of Moreland Properties told The Real Deal that both spec homes and land in Tarrytown have become cheaper recently. In the land series, 78703 still sat well above its 2021 level in 2024.
For a buyer, this changes what comparable sales mean. Two Tarrytown houses with the same square footage can be very different purchases. On one, most of the price may be the lot, and the original house may come down or be gutted. On the other, the price covers a finished, livable house on a lot of similar value. A blended price per square foot treats these as the same thing. A buyer weighing a remodel against a rebuild faces the same question we covered for Zilker and Barton Hills, with higher land values in play.
The sales no median includes
The second reason the headline numbers fall short is that many of Tarrytown's most expensive homes never show up in them. "Most of our sales of luxury homes are never hitting the public market, so nobody knows what they're selling for," Deane told The Real Deal.
That changes from year to year as well. Deane described a home on Northumberland Road that sold in the $5 million range. She said she would normally have sold it privately, but she listed it on the open market because she needed the visibility.
The public data moves with those decisions. In years when more sellers list publicly, the MLS sample includes more high-end homes. In years when they sell privately, those homes drop out of the sample and the published median looks weaker.
Well-built Tarrytown homes still sell quickly
If falling medians meant falling demand, the better Tarrytown homes would be selling slowly. The October record shows the opposite. Across Austin, buyers have real leverage. Unlock MLS's October 2026 figures, reported by the Austin American-Statesman, put the city median at $550,000. City sales were down 14.6% from October 2025. Homes across the metro averaged 76 days on market and closed at 92.2% of their original asking price. KXAN reported 5.7 months of inventory in the city for October.
Luxury homes have moved faster than the rest of the market. Unlock MLS figures reported by the Statesman in September showed homes priced at $1 million or more averaging 58 days on market in July, against 82 days for homes priced between $250,000 and $300,000. The article attributed the difference to cash buyers who are less exposed to borrowing costs.
That puts 2304 Indian Trail in context. It went under contract in six days, in a slow week, at $830 per square foot. The house dates to 1947 and was taken down to the studs and rebuilt in 2012. That week's most expensive contract, a 2024 home on Live Oak Ridge Road in West Lake Hills, also went under contract within about two weeks. The Real Deal quoted the tally's compiler describing "continued demand for newer construction in established, highly desirable neighborhoods."
Taken together, these figures show Tarrytown's prices separating by house. Homes where the lot, the finish work and the price fit together are going under contract in days. Homes where the asking price assumes the 2022 land market, or where a buyer has to fund the work the seller skipped, stay on the market longer, and their closing prices pull the averages down.
How to price one house here
In practice, a Tarrytown offer this winter starts with two separate questions. The first is what the lot is worth on its own, given its street, size and setting. The second is what the house on it adds, or costs, once you account for its age, layout and the quality of any renovation. A 1950s ranch that needs everything is priced mostly as land. A carefully rebuilt bungalow like the one on Indian Trail carries a premium for finished work that a buyer does not have to take on. The neighborhood median is little help with either question.
For a buyer, citywide inventory and longer marketing times mean room to negotiate on homes that have been listed for a while. That leverage is weakest on the homes most worth buying. For a seller, it means pricing against recent sales of similar homes on similar lots, not against the headline trend. We cover that in more detail in our guide to preparing a Tarrytown home for sale. Buyers still deciding between Tarrytown and its neighbors can start with our comparison of Tarrytown, Pemberton Heights and Bryker Woods and the Tarrytown neighborhood page.
A few direct questions
Did Tarrytown home values fall in 2025? The average sale price did. It fell 11%, from $1.7 million in 2024 to $1.5 million in 2025, across 252 sales. That figure includes a real cooling from pandemic-era prices and also changes in which homes sold and whether they sold publicly.
Is a one-month median for 78703 useful? Only as a rough signal. The July 2026 figure rested on 18 sales across the whole ZIP, so a few closings at either end of the price range can move it sharply.
Are buyers getting discounts in Tarrytown right now? Citywide, homes in October 2026 closed at an average of 92.2% of original asking price. In Tarrytown, discounts depend on the house. Homes that are well finished and priced in line with recent sales are still going under contract in days.
A Tarrytown price is best judged one lot and one house at a time. If you are weighing an offer or a list price this winter, The Petri Group can walk through the recent sales on your street with you. Receive Exclusive Listings in Your Inbox to see new Tarrytown homes as they come to market.